A powerful post was recently published entitled Everything Doesn’t Happen for a Reason by Tim Lawrence. Before you continue to read the following, please read his impactful words.
This post has resonated with many – especially the epatient community that faces incredible struggles each day. It is something I often tell my friends who try to reassure me that everything happens to a reason, but few understand until they really experience true pain and hardship.
Lawrence quotes his friend, Megan Devine:
I haven’t written for a while. There was too much to say and nothing to say at the same time. I’ve been broken in the last year and a half in ways I didn’t think I could be broken. I’ve lost myself and am not sure that I will find myself. In my life, I’ve been through a lot, but particularly in these last 9 months I have encountered some of the worst moments of my life. I have lost nearly everything. Much of what has been lost cannot be fixed, it can only be carried.
In the midst of loss and desolation, I am struggling right now as to my purpose in life. Why am I getting out of bed, taking a shower, going to therapy, eating food, breathing, taking insulin? I don’t really have a purpose. I’ve lost what I care about the most. I have no direction for the future.
I have nothing to set my mind to, no goals to accomplish, no reason to try to make things better when things do not get better – different at times, but not better and often they get worse. I will always be sick in far too many ways. Again, these things cannot be fixed, only carried.
Last night I was reading a book on structural dissociation and as I come to the end an important point stood out – the idea of bearing witness. The idea that everything does not happen for a reason but we can bear witness to each other’s suffering which is consequential and profound in itself.
I immediately wrote an email to my closest friends expressing the importance of bearing witness and how I need someone to bear witness to what I am going through and what I have been through. I need someone to bear witness because I need another to use what they learn from me, from my suffering to help others. There’s no stopping things from getting worse, for me at least. However, I can share my story and perhaps in the meaninglessness of suffering, attempt save others in a way I cannot be saved.
There was a really sappy chick-flick that came out in 2004 with Richard Gere and Susan Serandon (and Jennifer Lopez) called Shall We Dance. And toward the end of the movie, Serandon’s character as the wife to Gere’s character explains why marriage is important:
We need a witness to our lives. There’s a billion people on the planet… I mean, what does any one life really mean? But in a marriage, you’re promising to care about everything. The good things, the bad things, the terrible things, the mundane things… all of it, all of the time, every day. You’re saying ‘Your life will not go unnoticed because I will notice it. Your life will not go un-witnessed because I will be your witness’.“
Bearing witness to life is important in itself whether in marriage, in friendship, or from those who care for us. Everyone has a fundamental need to be seen, heard, and respected. When one bears witness, they are recognizing this need.
Bearing witness to suffering though takes greater strength and courage. Bearing witness to suffering holds greater significance.
In a HuffPost article – Compassion: Universally Misunderstood, this notion of bearing witness is wonderfully described as a form of compassion:
A standard dictionary definition of compassion would read something like, “a sensitivity to suffering in self and others with a commitment to try to alleviate it”. This encapsulates two basic processes. The first is the courage to turn towards, engage and be in touch with pain and distress, rather than opting to avoid or ignore it. The second is the preparedness to acquire the wisdom we need to behave appropriately in the face of suffering.
I am here—I have lived—because they chose to love me. They loved me in their silence, in their willingness to suffer with me, alongside me, and through me. They loved me in their desire to be as uncomfortable, as destroyed, as I was, if only for a week, an hour, even just a few minutes.
I’ve talked with my therapist about therapy being, to an extent, hospice care – trying to make things less worse, hurt just a bit less. But if the last week has proven anything, there is no making things less worse or hurt any less. So therapy is not just hospice care.
It’s not about making things comfortable or stopping things from getting worse, though I wish that could be and maybe I will find parts of that in what I do in therapy. I think it is more simply having someone bear witness to my suffering – to say I existed and when I don’t exist anymore that something I said or did helped another. It’s having someone to suffer with me, alongside me, turning toward the pain and distress so that it is realized as something that actually was endured. Accepting that it is, was, and will be and that it will not go unnoticed.
Bearing witness. When I’m at the homeless coalition I bear witness to the lives of many more disenfranchised than I. When I’m in the hospital on a psychiatric hold, I bear witness to the lives of those left without a voice. When I go to therapy or a doctors appointment, write an email or send a text or tweet, I’m allowing others to bear witness to my struggles in the hopes they might use it to have compassion for another and offer them the acknowledgment in their moments of despair.
Right now, I ask that you bear witness to my litany of medical and mental health illnesses:
- Type 1 Diabetes
- Celiac Disease
- Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis/Inflammatory Arthritis
- Herniated discs in my cervical spine
- Occipital neuralgia
- Cervicogenic headaches
- Chronic Pain
- Hiatal Hernia with GERD
- Borderline Personality Disorder
I ask you to bear witness to the complications that all these diseases and the restrictions they impose on my life.
I ask you to bear witness to the abuse and trauma I’ve suffered, the poverty I am experiencing, the suicides I’ve attempted.
I ask you to bear witness to the loss of what I once thought I would be and what I hoped to accomplish – dreams that cannot be.
I don’t need pity. Rather, I need compassion, to not go unseen, unheard in the midst of despair and chaos. I need someone to bear witness. In that way, all is not lost.
Thank you for bearing witness as you can.
Who wrote this?
Hi Dave – Erin wrote this in 2015 or so.
Ah. It was quite confusing! I’ll suggest that if you re-post more, it would help to add a note in italics at top saying that.
Also, of all her extraordinary posts, is there a reason this one was picked for right now?
Thank you for keeping her work in circulation.
Hi Dave: Sorry for the confusion! I didn’t want to change the flow of her writing or the formatting by putting a note at the top, so I put a little note on the “About” page saying that she passed and that I am maintaining the site. I picked this one because it spoke to me, but I do plan to review and repost all of the completed ones. It has taken some time to circle back to it, but my intention was strengthened yesterday when I read your lovely post after her death. Keep an eye out for more of them over the next month.
Thank you, Ron for posting this. I know Erin took down some of her posts and others, she never posted. It’s a fitting tribute on the day of her birth. Sending love to you, my friend.